Principle in Brief
Successful businesspeople stand on ground that is “crumbling beneath their feet,” wrote economist Joseph Schumpeter in 1942. He described creative destruction as “the process of industrial mutation” which “incessantly revolutionizes the economic structure from within, incessantly destroying the old one, incessantly creating the new one.”
As entrepreneurs create new businesses, products, services, processes, methods or types of organizations, less-effective ones become obsolete. It is apparent that consumers benefit as new alternatives that better serve them are brought to market. What is not obvious is that, over the long term, creative destruction benefits virtually everyone. It makes people throughout society better off, not only by continually creating better products and services, but also by creating better, safer jobs available to more people.
Those whose businesses or jobs are threatened or lost due to creative destruction often don’t take this long-term view and try to stop it. When they succeed, progress is stifled, disproportionately harming those who are worst off. Progress is maintained by ensuring those who are hurt in the short term learn new skills and have the opportunity to benefit long term from innovation and higher productivity.
At Koch, we recognize that the future is unknown and unknowable. This is why our Vision is open ended and embraces creative destruction. It focuses us on building the capabilities that enable us to continually create new opportunities and transform. This requires seeking disruptive innovations through internal development and acquisitions, and shedding products, assets and businesses that are unprofitable or worth more to others. When we drive creative destruction faster than our best competitors, we are successful.
Creative destruction originates with employees who are principled entrepreneurs, who recognize that however well they are doing today will soon not be good enough and are willing to change the paradigms, methods and tools that helped them succeed in the past. This happens when employees find a role where they have the opportunity, ability and passion to innovate and create value, thereby experiencing the glorious feeling of accomplishment.
Understand It Better
Examples
Below are some examples of creative destruction. Each example highlights what was created and what was displaced. As you read, consider how society progressed and benefited from creative destruction.
- Music
- Manufacturing
- Banking
- Medical Care
Today we stream music from our phones, easily choose specific songs on demand, and even listen while underwater. There were many products and services that were developed (created) and went away (destruction) to get to this point, including cassette tapes, CDs, and MP3 players. In the sweep of human history, it wasn't that long ago that the only way to hear music was to experience it live.
Modern manufacturing uses electronic monitoring to reduce or eliminate the need to send people into dangerous or physically demanding areas. Advanced monitoring and computing make it much easier, more accurate, and safer to understand how machines are performing.
It’s payday! Run your paper check to the bank. Just kidding. Modern-day banking makes it easy to skip the physical bank: direct deposit, online cash deposit and online payments. While this might mean fewer bank tellers doing paper transactions, it means more people employed as IT developers, call center support, and IT security.
The doctor is in – but you don’t have to be. With video calls, electronic charts and paperless prescriptions, telemedicine is a real alternative for many situations. Creative destruction doesn’t always mean something goes away entirely – people still see the doctor – but the method is different.
Give it a try
The power of these principles happens through application. There’s no substitute for learning as you apply.
- Talk to someone more experienced than you. Ask them for examples of creative destruction they’ve seen in the industry during their career.
- Discuss ways creative destruction could play out for your team/business over the next several years.
- Reflect: How have you dealt with creative destruction in the past? What did you learn?
- What are some examples of creative destruction you have witnessed during your life? What was created and what went away?
- What technological advances are driving creative destruction today?
- What are some things our team can do to drive creative destruction?
- Creative destruction often results in changes to jobs, companies and industries. What would happen if we tried to stop creative destruction? What can help people adapt when creative destruction happens?